28. Nov 2023
New thinking and terminology is needed to meet climate goals and secure sustainable carbon supply.
The focus of climate policy has been, and to a large extent still is, the decarbonisation of the energy sector, where significant progress has been made in the use of alternative energy sources such as solar, wind, hydro, geothermal and green hydrogen as an energy carrier. Decarbonisation is the right term here because all these options do not rely on carbon-based fossil fuels. In contrast, the products of industrial sectors such as chemicals, derived materials, plastics, and construction products are predominantly carbon-based and cannot be decarbonised by their very nature. Even in the energy sector, some applications such as aviation or shipping will not be electrified in the foreseeable future and require carbon-based fuels.
The current policy focus of carbon management is on CO2 only, the ongoing public consultation in Brussels reduces carbon management to carbon capture and CO2 management. Limiting carbon management to CO2 management is not sufficient as it misses the whole aspect of carbon feedstock supply and the circular economy, which is very important for Europe as an industrial location.
In this position paper, the Renewable Carbon Initiative (RCI), supported by CO2 Value Europe (CVE), proposes a broader definition of carbon management:
Comprehensive carbon management goes beyond CO2 emissions, capture and long-term storage. It decouples the whole industry from fossil feedstocks, eliminates the use of fossil carbon wherever possible and allocates renewable carbon (from biomass, CO2, and recycling) as efficiently and effectively as possible where carbon use is unavoidable. The aim is to achieve the lowest possible CO2 emissions, reduce the need for carbon removal to achieve net zero, and provide a secure supply of renewable carbon to all dependent industries such as chemicals and materials. Truly sustainable carbon cycles can only be achieved when carbon is recognised as a feedstock in carbon management strategies. Proper comprehensive carbon management will defossilise the carbon-dependent materials and energy sectors and decarbonise the remaining energy sector. Carbon Capture and Storage should only be used for the remaining share of truly unavoidable emissions. AT
The “RCI Position paper on Comprehensive Carbon Management” can be found here: